Johnny Placide questions VAR after Haiti penalty appeals rejected

Johnny Placide demands answers after FIFA World Cup 2026 VAR ignores two Haiti penalty appeals against Scotland (Image via Getty)

Haiti were left frustrated after a 1-0 loss to Scotland in their FIFA World Cup 2026 Group C opener in Boston on Sunday. While John McGinn’s first-half goal gave Scotland all three points, the biggest talking point came after two second-half handball appeals involving Scotland defender Grant Hanley. Haiti captain Johnny Placide said his team felt they were denied two clear penalties and questioned why VAR did not step in during either incident.

Johnny Placide questions VAR after two Grant Hanley handball appeals

The first controversial moment came in the 73rd minute when Grant Hanley appeared to move his hand toward a cross inside the penalty area. Just five minutes later, another appeal followed when Hanley seemed to use his arm to block a shot from Jean-Ricner Bellegarde. Despite protests from Haiti’s players, play continued on both occasions and VAR did not recommend a review. After the match, Jean-Ricner Bellegarde also reacted to the decisions. In a post on X, the midfielder wrote: “I would like to know the opinion of the VAR.”Haiti captain Johnny Placide said the team was not trying to make excuses for the defeat but wanted answers about the decisions that affected the match. “We waited for VAR to intervene, we waited for explanations, but nothing came,” Placide said. “As players, we dedicate our lives to this competition, so naturally we want clarity.”

Haiti captain Johnny Placide calls for transparency from officials

Placide said Haiti respected Scotland’s performance and accepted the final result, but believed the team deserved a clearer explanation from the officials.“All we are asking for is transparency,” he said. “If those incidents were not penalties, then tell us why. Show us the reasoning. Let the fans understand the decision-making process.”The goalkeeper added that accountability should be part of the sport, especially on football’s biggest stage.

John McGinn goal gives Scotland victory despite Haiti frustration

While Haiti focused on the disputed handball incidents, Scotland held on to the lead created by John McGinn’s first-half goal. The result gave Steve Clarke’s side an important win to begin their Group C campaign. Placide admitted the mood inside Haiti’s dressing room was difficult after the final whistle.“The dressing room was silent after the final whistle,” he said. “Many players felt heartbroken because we believed we had done enough to get something from the match.” He added that Haiti only wanted the same treatment and respect given to every team competing at the World Cup.